Here are the things I included - but maybe you have stuff on hand already - and many of these (like kisses, candy canes, etc) come 8-10 to a pack.
Buy a little sanitizer and attach this cute "santa-tizer" tag to it! thank you to "Main Event Prints" blog for the printable.
U-create Crafts made this great M&M printable using religious Christmas Story references.
This is one of my favorites. This is a beautiful printable by Darling Doodles <3
Chapstick! Dollar tree had Christmas ones for $1 or other kinds 3 for $1. Fun for little ones made this cute tag.
The Legend of the Candy cane is a good printable or you can use this bookmark printable from My computer is my Canvas that explains the symbolism of the candy cane legend.
I found this idea at How Does She and made my own tag using fun fonts from fontmeme.
I modified this tag because it was meant for a mixture of foods. Because of COVID, people (especially our older friends) would prefer bagged items instead of prepared food. So, I just cut off the bottom of the tag and only included bugles and pretzels. From Caramel Potatoes.
I love the Happy Home Fairy and she has the cutest free printables. Including some corny jokes in the stocking would be great!
If you want to include a Hershey's chocolate bar (I ended up not doing this one because it was $5...but it's cute) here is a printable from Esty. Lastly, I wrote out a card with "Merry Kiss-mas" (which you could also print here from Etsy for $3 or elf kisses here) and included colored pencils and an inspiritional word search and coloring book from the Dollar store - saying "May your Christmas be inspirational and full of color" :)
I put all of the items into a stocking from the Dollar store and I'm going to deliver them on the 22nd with a note attached that says, "DO NOT OPEN UNTIL CHRISTMAS EVE OR CHRISTMAS DAY" :)
Merry Christmas and God bless! May your Christmas be full of love, peace and joy...